Wait… Vaccines Don’t Cause Autism?
Andrew Wakefield published his work linking the Measles, Mumps, and Rubella vaccine (MMR) to intestinal inflammation that would cause the eventual development of autism in 1998. This publication struck fear in parents across the world and the results of these claims lingered for many years to come. His research ignited a wide spread anti-vaccination movement that unfortunately was based on scientifically insignificant research. Even though the scientific community retracted his studies 12 years later, many people are still justifying their choice to avoid vaccinating their children with Wakefield’s faulty claims.
Let’s take a moment to break apart Wakefield’s argument. Why was it retracted? Well according to an informative article from Philadelphia Children’s Hospital, let’s look at the facts. Wakefield only recruited 12 children, all from England, and only one of them was female. With a sample of this nature, I would find it hard to justify that any findings could be applied to an entire population. Anyway, at first glance, it seems alarming that 8 of these 12 children developed intestinal complaints and autism within one month of receiving MMR. However, this is completely understandable when given the context. “90% of children in England received MMR at the time this paper was written” and the age when MMR is typically administered to children is also the same age when symptoms of autism typically begin to emerge (Offit, Handy, Bodenstab). Therefore, a correlation between recent MMR vaccination and the development of autism symptoms should be expected.
Let me point out, in the scientific community, the only valid mechanism of determining causation is through experimentation. In order to be considered an experiment, a variable must be directly manipulated. In Wakefield’s study, he merely gathered a very small group of children, who had all received MMR, and who were all within the normal age range for the appearance of autism. He then attempted to claim that MMR caused autism. He then attempted to justify this claim with parent testimony and testing of intestinal symptoms after symptoms of autism had already developed. None of these circumstances resemble a scientifically credible experiment. I think with this understanding, it is clear to see that under no circumstances was a causational relationship rightly justified. While Wakefield may have found a correlation between the MMR vaccine and the development of autism, this was likely only due to an age similarity. This correlation gives us no reason to believe that MMR causes autism. Like my wise psychology professor drilled into my mind…
Correlation DOES NOT determine causation!”
-UNC’s very wise psychology professor, Jeannie Loeb
Wakefield’s study was not verified by other independent scientists. Other researchers performed well controlled studies with large sample sizes that focused on the scope of autism disorder itself and how it relates to MMR. These studies all support a similar conclusion; autism develops in the nervous system early in the womb and is not caused by environmental factors later in child development, like the MMR vaccine.
Measles Outbreak?!?
…Am I at Risk?
NPR reports recent news that measles is on the rise all across the globe. This raises the question… who is at risk? Most of you might think that only those who have not been vaccinated against this highly contagious disease should be worried. Turns out, thats not the case! As outbreaks of measles rise in the United States, making sure you’re up to date on your vaccinations should jump to the top of your priority list.
The topic of “revaccination” is gaining a popular following. The current measles vaccination is an attenuated vaccine, meaning, the measles pathogen present in the vaccine is much less virulent than the normal pathogen, but it is still viable (or alive) in order to produce an immune response. This attenuated measles vaccine provides over 90% protection against the virus. Amazing! Unfortunately, people vaccinated prior to 1968 should consider getting a measles booster, or another dose of the vaccine. The vaccine used to protect against measles prior to 1968 only had an inactivated or killed form of the pathogen. The CDC warns that this form of vaccine is not effective and urges people to get the current attenuated MMR vaccine if they are unsure of their vaccination status.
“Another dose of the same vaccine?”, “I’ve already had this shot once before!”, concerns of overdose might come to some people’s minds. This is a reasonable concern, but don’t worry! This is a win win situation. If you received the inactivated vaccine as a child and you get the current attenuated MMR vaccine, you will be protected during the current outbreak. However, if you are unsure which vaccine you received as a child, go ahead and get the most up to date MMR. William Schaffner, an infectious disease and vaccine expert, assures that if you are already immune, it may not help much, but an additional dose won’t hurt you in any way. Better to be safe than sorry! If you’re still not convinced, you can get blood work done to determine your immunity status. Personally, extra needles and visits to the doctor don’t appeal to me. Good news to wrap things up; most folks born before 1957 don’t need to worry with additional measles boosters because the virus was so wide spread during that time, they have most likely already been exposed. Phew!